Tuman and Parker Criticize Quan’s National Journal Comments

Mayor Jean Quan. Photo by Spencer Whitney.

Mayor Jean Quan. Photo by Spencer Whitney.

Mayoral candidates Joe Tuman and Bryan Parker have taken Mayor Jean Quan to task following the mayor’s controversial comments in an interview with the National Journal this week.

Her comments were totally insensitive,” said Tuman, a political analyst for CBS5 news on television and KCBS radio.

[caption id=”attachment_28258″ align=”alignnone” width=”300″]Mayoral candidate Joe Tuman Mayoral candidate Joe Tuman[/caption]

He has worked for the past 27 years teaching politics, law, and communication at San Francisco State University. What Quan said “implies that you should be concerned if African Americans are in your neighborhood,” Tuman said. “I don’t think she is a racist.”

“Race is a major fault line for us in Oakland,” he said. “We need to talk more openly about it, but this is not the way to provoke the discussion. The African American community is a source of our strength.”

Parker also criticized Quan.

“I’m sure many, as I was, were taken aback by these remarks,” Parker said. “I think the comments miss on two fronts. First, her comments suggest that her belief is that there is a negative stigma associated with having a high number of African Americans in Oakland.”

Mayoral candidate Bryan Parker

Mayoral candidate Bryan Parker

“Second, like many of her other actions, her comments lack the structure of thoughtful leadership,” he added.

Parker served on the Oakland Workforce Investment Board and is a member of the Oakland Port Commissiono. Also an attorney, he works as a health care executive.

As originally published, Quan spokesman Sean Maher said that the mayor’s answer was so “truncated” as to be distorted.

In the interview with the National Journal, Quan was asked: “What remains your biggest challenge?”

Her reply: “Well, my challenge is to let people know what the new Oakland looks like. “Somebody just sent me an email saying, ‘Oh, you should have more black police since more than 50 percent of your residents are black.’ And I’m like, ‘Actually, no, 28 percent of my residents are black, but we’re pretty evenly divided between blacks, whites, Latinos, and Asians these days.’ But that’s their image of Oakland–and this is somebody who lives in the Bay Area.”

For Quan’s full interview with the National Journal, go to www.nationaljournal.com/next-economy/america-360/can-oakland-escape-san-francisco-s-shadow-20131006

Share Button
Print Friendly


  1. Marquis

    You guys just don’t get it.. it’s people like Quan that are really hurting this city. She cried and begged to be a Mayor now that she’s in position she can’t handle it..she does not have a clue. And as for the hiring process with Law enforcement …it is true the city hires more Caucasian Officers than African American Officers. These citizens of Oakland are very aware of the situation.. The African American people realize that the city is trying to run them out! while other races move in.. Do the math, figure it out! This is going to continue until change come about!


    I have no qualms with Quan as many outsiders do, and what I read above didn’t seem racist or insensitive. I’m all for honest, frank discussion, not needlessly stirring the pot!

Post a comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *